Tuesday, October 2, 2012

HR Design Meeting: The Community Speaks

My sources tell me that Varsity Hall in Union South was completely packed for today's meeting on HR Design.  At this "informational session" the HR team spoke for 60 minutes, leaving just 30 minutes for Q & A.

During that time, 18 people were able to ask questions.  Here's the list-- some people repeated a question when the first iteration did not get a satisfactory answer  I'm told the most frequent responses  from the team were "There is no easy answer" and "There is no one answer."
  1. If there is a perception of hierarchy [between the academic and classified staff], why has the faculty not been included in this process?
  2. In which category (academic or the new university staff) do the trades fit?  Will pay increases (living wage?) be honored?
  3. How was data used in these plans?  
  4. What are the current plans for staff diversity?
  5. What does governance mean for university (classified) staff? 
  6. How are salaries affected by the compensation plans (flexibility and living wages)? 
  7. What is university staff governance?  It is compared to the academic staff version, but many of us don't know what that means.
  8. What are the advantages of moving or staying in the current classified staff system?
  9. Which changes apply to student hourlies?  Does the living wage apply?
  10. What is the difference between a student living wage and the living wage mentioned for other staff?
  11. The faculty are managers, but have no training.  How will they be held accountable?
  12. How will employees and managers be held accountable?
  13. The HR committee needs to realize faculty are not interested in HR and the hierarchy will not disappear.  They are overwhelmed and have no time for administrative tasks.  They need more support.  You can't expect that type of cultural change from a training.
  14. What is the minimum living wage?
  15. What if these changes doesn't get approved in time, and implementation is held up?
  16. How are retiring staff affected?
  17. How is collective bargaining affected?
  18. What assurance do we have that merit pay is not another form of favoritism?  We need a system that is fair to everyone.

These are good questions. I wonder how many people on campus even know this process is occurring...
You have read this article with the title . You can bookmark this page URL https://educationarticlesfromexperts.blogspot.com/2012/10/hr-design-meeting-community-speaks.html. Thanks!

Just the "Facts" on HR Design

Yesterday's Faculty Senate meeting at UW-Madison provided a wonderful illustration of how the cycle of widening economic inequality is regenerated through the actions of colleges and universities.
A Word Cloud Illustration of the Terms Contained in HR Design's Strategic Plan Components.  Word size is relative to frequency in document. 
Here's a thumbnail sketch of the process leading to the prioritization of markets over equity as depicted above. (In case you can't find it, "equity" is that tiny word hidden under "Job" on the left, above)

  1. Wisconsin's conservative politicians slash investments in public higher education. This is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the reduction of human capital formation via public institutions.  The following steps are also required.
  2. Public colleges and universities struggle to respond. They have multiple options, one of which is to fight the disinvestment while protecting its most vulnerable programs, employees, and students, but instead they adopt a suggestion provided by fiscally conservative liberals: turn to the market for ideas and support!
  3. University administrators promote a new set of principles for the allocation of resources based on market rationales-- efficiency, effectiveness, and performance! Of course equity will be preserved, they say, but that's "up to you and your managers-- the power is all yours and the devil is in the details!" Yep, sure is.
  4. These new principles and plans are developed "in collaboration" with the very few faculty, staff, and students who, in the midst of great economic and time constraints, are actually available for these discussions.  The "opportunity" for a new model is repeatedly emphasized as an inherently good thing, a wise thing, and one that will help us "help ourselves." These discussions result in a set of stylized proposals resting on unquestioned assumptions.
  5. The plans are presented to "stakeholders."  They are described as based on "facts" of unquestionable validity and declared "not part of an effort to corporatize the university."  Such declarations are made without justification-- but because stakeholders are insufficiently equipped to respond, time-constrained, exhausted from overwork, and accustomed to being ignored by the administration, few offered any questions.
  6. Thus, even the faculty-- purportedly the best-educated stakeholders-- sit quietly.  Unquestioning. No sifting and winnowing.  Happy to have someone else solve their "problems," especially if it means money will soon enter their pockets.
  7. And with that, university administration has "engaged" its publics in the relevant discussions and can proceed with its plans.  It will pass the new agenda through all channels and deliver it, fully rubber-stamped, back to the gleeful Legislature.
  8. Thus, we in higher education have "helped ourselves." 
  9. Fast forward 5 years:  in many units, the gap in pay between research staff employed in high-demand fields and those assisting with teaching and learning will have grown.  Substantial numbers of jobs will move from employee to contractor status, since the new system guarantees a living wage only to employees-- not contractors-- and as we know, living wages are expensive! The number of mid-level bureaucrats (managers) on campus will have doubled and increased their power, as they now control budgets through their special analyses of employees' market value.  But it will be impossible to document all of these changes since the data will continue to be held in an administrative unit that decides how it displays results and is only required to respond to request from administrators, not employees. 
But don't worry, folks, this isn't corporatization.

And never fear, since shared governance will continue to reign.  If by that term, you mean that employees will have "input."


Notes:

1. Bob Lavigna pronounced the HR plan "not corporatization" three times during yesterday's Faculty Senate meeting.
2. While Lavigna said that shared governance meant "joint decision-making" (in response to a question I raised) the HR plan never mentions joint decision-making and instead mentions "input" 19 times.



You have read this article corporatize / equity / HR design / marketization / markets with the title . You can bookmark this page URL https://educationarticlesfromexperts.blogspot.com/2012/10/just-on-hr-design.html. Thanks!
Monday, October 1, 2012

More Questions on HR Design

In advance of this afternoon's meeting, I received this very helpful document from the Wisconsin University Union, which summarizes the HR Design plan elements and how they compare to current practice, while raising some critical questions about each element.

Here are some questions that I think are especially deserving of response:

  • Will the university staff assembly, created by HR Design, preempt or potentially undermine the re-establishment of unions?  
  • Why aren’t all contractors (over $5K) included in the living wage provisions, consistent with the City of Madison policy? UW has shifted to using contractors for custodial and food-service positions, and currently pays custodians just $8/hour. 
  • What provisions prevent a hiring authority from defining the “employing unit” as so limited as to “force” a layoff? 
  • What is the evaluation plan to assess the impacts of these radical changes?

You have read this article compensation / HR design / layoffs / neoliberalism / unions / UW Madison with the title . You can bookmark this page URL https://educationarticlesfromexperts.blogspot.com/2012/10/more-questions-on-hr-design.html. Thanks!